Beyond the Stars: How to Get Effective Reviews from Customers

Beyond the Stars: How to Get Effective Reviews from Customers

You’ve heard it said that consumers are the new marketing channel. When they talk, others listen. You should listen, too, so you know how to get effective reviews from customers.

Here’s what we mean.

There are 5-star reviews and there are effective reviews. Unfortunately, getting the former doesn’t guarantee the latter.

” ‘Good’ is not always positive. Remember, a ‘good’ review is the type of review that’s useful to the people who come along behind you.” – Alan Henry

Put another way, most businesses see 5-star reviews as the ticket to success, while most customers just want the insights that come along with those stars.

Of course, star ratings do matter. But if there’s no substance to the actual reviews, customers may look elsewhere.

The following example is instructive:

vague online review

Image Source: TrustPilot

If most of your five-star reviews look like this one, don’t expect prospective customers to be overly wowed.

It’s About Quality, Not Just Stars

We’re betting when you research service providers or products online, you pay more attention to detailed reviews and recommendations than the generic star ratings.

In fact, the more detailed the review, the more likely you are to visit a business’s website and enter the conversion funnel.

What Effective Reviews Look Like

You probably already encourage customers to review your business. But how can you nudge them to leave truly effective reviews?

Mad Dog Cycles review, Yelp

Image Source: Yelp Reviews

Before we talk strategy, let’s look closer at the benefits of effective reviews:

  • Effective reviews motivate businesses to continually refine their products and services.
  • An effective review also helps prospective customers make good decisions
  • This kind of authentic feedback restores consumer trust in online reviews as a whole.

Now, take a look at these tips from Trustpilot:

Customer Reviews tips

Image Source: Trustpilot

In a perfect world, every customer would follow these tips. But real-world customers require a little encouragement.

Attributes that Drive Action

No surprises; there are lots of review platforms are out there—with Yelp, Facebook, and Google firmly in the lead. And don’t forget niche reviewing sites like Healthgrades, TripAdvisor, Zillow, SeniorAdvisor, and … well, you get the idea.

If customers are reviewing you, they can do so on virtually any review platform. Why not guide them to the most helpful review options?

First off, a few basic rules:

  1. Determine which niche review sites are most critical to your industry.
  2. Direct customers towards a specific (non-Yelp) review platform where you want to see more reviews.
  3. With help from Banyan, customize your review invitation message to make the process easy.
  4. Carefully follow review policies to ensure your reviews stay secure and visible.
  5. Respond promptly to all incoming reviews.

Banyan reviews, customized review request mockup

Unsurprisingly, it takes consistent, daily effort to get effective reviews. So, get in the habit of asking.

How to Get Effective Reviews, Not Just Stars

What else can you do to get effective reviews?

Bottom line, incredible customer service is the most important key. And when things don’t go well, a prompt response is also critical.

“Although it can be difficult to swallow at times, you want your customers to leave honest reviews of their experience. If you do your part in providing what you promise, (rest) assured that the majority of your reviews (will be) positive.” – Fresh Lime

One more thing. Every positive experience can be turned into an effective review if you remember to ask while customers are with you.

Be Realistic

Of course, no one business has a perfect track record. And that’s okay.

According to Amy Osmond Cook (Forbes contributor), when online reviews average an A-minus, conversion rates tend to be higher.

Studies appear to support Cook’s claim. On average, star ratings between 4.2 and 4.5 hit the sweet spot and help customers convert. Such reviews also look more authentic and build trust.

So you don’t need all five-star reviews to win new customers. But you do need effective reviews and responses:

TripAdvisor review

Image Source: TripAdvisor

Be Respectful

As the above example shows, it pays to be respectful and responsive to every review. Your goodwill and prompt response will go a long way toward protecting your online reputation.

As needed, take conversations offline for customers who appear to be in attack mode.

In short, keep it classy.

How to Get Effective Reviews, SeniorAdvisor review

Image Source: SeniorAdvisor

Specific vs. Generic Information

So, what is it that makes some customers go into detail in their reviews while other reviewers say next to nothing?

Here’s exhibit A, a review from EMI Health:

Patient review for EMI Health

Image Source: Google Reviews

Not only did the reviewer share specific details about her experience, but she also strengthened a B2B relationship.

Even better, EMI responded promptly and respectfully.

Now, for exhibit B, a dermatology review:

Example of patient review, generic comments

Image Source:

While both examples are positive, the first includes more meaningful details about the reviewer’s experience.

Why the differences?

Some of it has to do with customer personality (not something you can change). But time crunches and vague requests can also lead to ineffective reviews.

Ask On Site

You can safely assume that most customers are in a hurry. If so, they’ll probably leave a star rating but not make specific comments.

To counter this tendency, ask customers for a review while they’re still with you. As needed, walk them through the basics and give them time to complete the review.

Here’s another easy idea you can try:


Rephrase Your Request

What do you ask customers before you text or email them the review link?

More often than not, comments like, “We’d love to know how your experience was today. Would you be willing to write a review and share the specifics with us?” are most effective.

The word “specifics” basically plants a seed in your customer’s mind that may blossom into a more detailed review.

You could also lead with, “You are one of our favorite customers. Would you be willing to share a little of your history with us in an online review? We know that would be valuable to other customers.”

The trick is to ask for reviews in a way that motivates customers to get specific.

Post Helpful Reviews

To encourage more insightful reviews, it also helps to post some of the best on your website in the form of testimonials.

This strategy puts effective reviews front and center for your website visitors.

Testimonial page from Marschall Road Animal Hospital

Image Source:

Also, when customers get specific, don’t be short on the praise! Tell them how much their words mean to you and how helpful their comments will be to others.

Customized Review Requests

As mentioned above, it matters how you ask customers to review you.

Generally, a simple “How was your experience?” will prompt a more detailed response than “Can you rate us?”

If you’re a Banyan reviews customer, you can also customize the invitation you text to customers.

Let’s say you’d like more helpful reviews on Google and Healthgrades. After connecting to your Google My Business page and Healthgrades in the Banyan app, you pull up a review template similar to this one:

Customized review invitation message, BirdEye

With a flexible template, you can customize your message to motivate effective reviews.

For example, you can change your default image and adjust your message to something like, “Hi Garrett, we’d love you to share the details of your visit today! Just click this link.”

Likewise, you can enable Facebook Recommendations on your Facebook Page so that customers can use specific tags to describe their experience.

Read more about Facebook Recommendations

Where to Go from Here

The world of online reviews grows every day, fed by the average consumer’s appetite for information:

“Today’s consumers consult an average of 10.4 sources of information before making a purchase. Voracious information seeking has become deeply ingrained … and we can envision no scenario in which they will see traditional marketing as a better provider of product information.” – Harvard Business Review

Well, there you have it. Online reviews are here to stay, and they’re much more than just star ratings.

As you work to provide your customers with a great experience, they’ll want to tell others. The easier you make the process, the more effective those reviews will be.


Need help with your reviews strategy? Check out our Banyan Reviews page.



The Terrible Online Review—and How to Turn It Around

A new review just appeared on your Facebook page. At first glance, you see a one-star rating. Your stomach clenches as you read the unflattering comments.

No one likes getting bad reviews. But they do happen, even to otherwise reputable practices or small businesses. Here’s how to turn customer feedback to your advantage, whether the reviews are lukewarm or downright terrible.

The Truth About Bad Reviews

In a 2017 consumer review survey, BrightLocal found that 85 percent of consumers trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations. What’s more, 2016 findings indicate that 68 percent of consumers would avoid a business altogether after reading negative reviews.

Luckily, the news gets better.

BrightLocal also reports that in 2017, the number of consumers who would avoid a business because of negative reviews dropped significantly: from 68 to 40 percent.

Is this a trend or anomaly? Only time can tell. But in an era of fake news (and more recently, fake Amazon reviews), it appears that consumers are less swayed by a bad review and more impressed by authenticity. And that’s good news for everyone.

Callout box, quote, Banyan blog, terrible reviews

Source: Vendasta


Clearly, negative reviews can serve a positive purpose.

Shane Barker, a contributor at, puts it this way: “When you display the bad reviews, there’s a much better chance people will believe the positive reviews. Which means that all the good parts highlighted in the positive reviews will have an impact on their decisions.”

According to Barker, including negative reviews with positive reviews also shows consumers that your business isn’t hiding something. Those bad reviews also help you learn from mistakes and may even offer greater dialogue with those you serve.

All the same, you need a clear strategy for dealing with those negative reviews.

As Dr. Duncan Simester of MIT Sloan suggests, “the infrequent nature of negative reviews may help to distinguish them from other reviews.” That’s why we pay more attention to the negative reviews, even if they’re biased, illogical, or downright false.

When They Go Low …

So, what should happen when your practice or business receives a review—good or bad? In a word: response.

Gain perspective

It’s easy to respond right away and thank someone for a great review. However, just one nasty review can knock the wind out of your sails. If you’re feeling defensive or angry, take a few minutes to distance yourself and gain perspective before taking action.

gain perspective, Banyan blog, reviews

Investigate the matter

As soon as you notice a negative review, perform a quick internal investigation with your staff, suggests marketing expert Neil Patel. What seems to be the underlying issue for this customer? Discuss the matter with your team and jot down your impressions.

Keep in mind that you can buy a little time by sending a preliminary response like, “So sorry to hear about your bad experience. We’re looking into the matter right now and will get back to you right away.”

However, if you’re a healthcare practitioner, you should volunteer to take the conversation offline (see “send a direct message,” below).

Show empathy

As a disarming tactic, always thank the reviewer for sharing feedback with you, even if that feedback is blatantly unfair or false. As the saying goes, “when they go low, you go high.” Politeness and empathy matter—always.

empathy statements, reviews

Sincerely apologize

Criticism can be tough to take. But if the reviewer’s concerns are valid, apologize and own your mistakes (e.g., “We’re so sorry you had a bad experience. Here’s what we plan to do about it”).

Avoid the ‘fake apology’ approach (e.g., “We’re sorry you are angry”).

Send a direct message

Is your reviewer’s tone measured—or inflammatory? Responding to someone in full attack mode is rarely a good idea.

To forestall a lot of back and forth, say something like, “We sense your frustration and would love to resolve your concerns. May we DM you?” or “We’d love to talk more about your experience today. Please call us!”

NOTE: This tactic is especially critical for medical professionals, who should not respond to bad reviews if private health information is mentioned. Always take it offline.

online reviews, Banyan 

Stay on top of reviews

As tempting as it may be to ignore a bad review, that’s the worst thing you can do. According to ReviewTrackers, 52 percent of customers expect a response within 7 days. But the best practice is to respond within 24 hours, if not sooner.

Even better, when you respond promptly to a bad review, the perception of your practice or business also improves.

Review Trackers, Banyan blog

Exceed expectations

You’re on your way to meeting customer expectations when you respond quickly to every review. But to really build trust, why not exceed their expectations? Offer a discount. When appropriate, go the extra mile with a card or flowers.

Zappos has a reputation for exceeding customer expectations, as shown below.


Zappos review

A Proactive Approach to Reviews

Now that you have a strategy for responding to negative reviews, it’s time to move to more proactive methods for getting positive reviews.

It should be obvious at this point that your online ratings will only be as good as your customer service. It’s your job to offer such a great experience to your patients and customers that bad reviews have no place to go but up.

Statista, what people look for in reviews, Banyan blog

According to Search Engine Land and BrightLocal, most consumers consider star rating and quantity of reviews as top indicators of a good business.

It follows, then, that as you invite patients or customers to leave you a review—especially after a positive experience—your star ratings and review quantity will both improve.

Know what customers are saying

Before you can improve your star rating and acquire more positive reviews, you need to know what customers are saying about you. Try these suggestions:

  1. At a minimum, set up Google Alerts on your phone so you can see new notifications when your business name is mentioned online.
  2. Manage and monitor reviews at a glance by partnering with Banyan. You can also respond to reviews in real time via your reviews dashboard.

Banyan reviews dashboard

Track your star ratings and total reviews

According to Neil Patel, an ideal rating lies anywhere between 4.2 and 4.5 stars. This rating accounts for the occasional negative or lukewarm review but still helps viewers see you in an overwhelmingly positive light.

With Banyan, you can see your average star rating and monitor it over time, along with the total number of reviews you’ve received. You can also filter by review sources, such as Yelp, Facebook, or Google.

Another proactive feature lets you target a goal for how many reviews you’d like to receive in a specified period.

Ask happy customers for reviews

Judging by the smiling, happy faces you see, you’ve just had a great interaction with a patient or customer. What better time to ask for a review?

Try these simple prompts:

  • You’re one of our favorite patients ever. Would you be willing to let us know how we did today? Watch for a review request on your phone.
  • It’s customers like you who make our day! Would you mind sharing your feedback so others can learn about us?
  • If you’re okay with it, we’d love to send you a quick review request so you can give us feedback right from your phone.
  • We’d love you to share how things went for you today. Do you have two minutes to give us some feedback?
  • We’re glad you had a good experience today. Would you be willing to share your feedback in a quick review? We’ll send it to your phone now.

If your patients or customers need help, stand by and walk them through the process. Most people are already signed into social accounts on their smartphones. If not, you can offer quick tips about signing in to Facebook or Gmail and then show them how easy it is to leave a review.

Just like that, you’re helping boost your online presence with every new review that comes in. Over time, the positive feedback will begin to edge out the negative reviews.

Sounds like a 5-star plan to us.

happy customer, Banyan blog

What are you doing to counter negative online reviews and create a positive experience for your patients and customers? We’d love to help—contact us anytime.